In 'Whose Thief is it Anyway?', players navigate the chaotic aftermath of a heist gone wrong in a small, quirky town known for its eccentric characters and oddball secrets. As the newly appointed detective with a dubious reputation, you must interrogate a host of suspects, each with their own ridiculous alibis and eccentric stories. Uncover clues in a series of hilarious, interconnected scenarios while trying to deduce 'who stole what from whom' before the town's annual Silly Hat Parade starts. The game allows for multiple endings based on your choices, humorously highlighting your missteps and victories along the way.