In "Whose Laughter Is It Anyway?", players take on the role of a struggling stand-up comedian who suddenly discovers a mysterious, comic artifact that allows them to channel the laughter of historic comedic icons. As they traverse through fragmented memories and uproarious scenarios, they must navigate various comedic styles and improvise their way through outrageous situations while contending with a rival comedian determined to steal the artifact. Choices made during performance scenes affect their popularity and relationships with zany side characters in this nonlinear tale of wit and laughter.