Set in a quirky town famous for its annual 'Whose Is It Anyway?' festival, players step into the shoes of an amateur detective who must solve a series of bizarre ownership disputes that have escalated to dramatic proportions. Characters include eccentric townsfolk, a mischievous raccoon, and supernatural entities claiming rights to unusual possessions. The game incorporates humor and unexpected plot twists as players gather clues, question peculiar witnesses, and ultimately decide the fate of quirky items like a haunted toaster or a mysterious painting. The choices made influence the ultimate resolution of the conflicts, leading to multiple humorous endings.