In 'Whose Is It Anyway?', you take on the role of a quirky private investigator hired to solve a series of ridiculous thefts in your small town. Each theft revolves around bizarre and oddly specific items: the town's last rubber chicken, a famous collection of mismatched socks, and the really important trophy for 'Most Enthusiastic Potluck Participant'. As you interact with eccentric townsfolk—each hiding secrets and comedic quirks—you must unravel a convoluted narrative filled with red herrings, outrageous alibis, and laugh-out-loud moments. Your choices shape the investigation, leading to multiple comedic endings based on how you interpret the clues or misinterpret them spectacularly.