In 'Whose Hellos Are These Anyway?', players step into the shoes of Max, a sarcastic freelance greeting card writer who tumbles into a world of chaos when they discover a series of mysterious, anonymous greetings popping up all over town. Each message reveals secrets, leads, and potential scandals involving local residents. The goal is to unravel the connections between the greetings and the townspeople while navigating hilarious dilemmas and quirky characters that Max encounters along the way. Players choose dialogue options to interact with local eccentrics, solve riddles, and uncover the true identities behind the enigmatic messages, leading to multiple endings filled with humor and unexpected turns.