In 'Whose Hell Is It Anyway?', players find themselves in a bizarre limbo where souls debate and negotiate which of them truly deserves to end up in hell. As the quirky character dubbed 'The Arbiter', you must engage in absurdly comedic trials, courtroom-style arguments, and tongue-in-cheek puns to determine the fates of a variety of eccentric souls. Each playthrough introduces you to an eclectic cast—from an overzealous mime who accidentally committed arson to a disgraced fortune teller who couldn't see her own downfall. Your choices influence the outcome and the ultimate 'punishments', leading to wildly different endings and laugh-out-loud moments.