In 'Whose Heart Is It Anyway?', players step into the shoes of Edna, an eccentric heart collector who lives in a peculiar world where people's emotions are stored in literal hearts. Following a freak accident during one of her heart heists, Edna inadvertently combines hearts, creating bizarre emotional hybrids that cause chaos in her town. Players navigate through a series of quirky quests, interacting with the townsfolk and their newly mixed emotions while solving puzzles based on emotional intelligence and social dynamics. As they juggle relationships with a colorful cast of characters, the player must ultimately decide whether to restore the hearts to their original owners or embrace the chaos for their own gain.