In 'Whose Heart Is It Anyway?', players assume the role of a quirky, unreliable coroner named Mort the Mortician, who discovers that a collection of odd, enchanted human hearts has gone missing from the morgue. Each heart belongs to a different character with their own dramatic and absurd backstory, resulting in a colorful cast ranging from a jilted romantic to a paranoid conspiracy theorist. As Mort, players must embark on an eccentric journey through the shadows of a quirky city, gathering clues, befriending eccentric townsfolk, and confronting the heart-thieves in laugh-out-loud encounters. The player’s choices determine which heart they choose to reclaim, unraveling wild tales and unexpected plot twists that challenge the concept of identity, love, and what it truly means to 'steal someone's heart'.