In 'Whose Heart Is It Anyway?', players assume the role of Charlie, a quirky yet morbidly curious coroner tasked with navigating the chaotic underbelly of a city where hearts are not just organs but coveted treasures. After discovering a black market of enchanted hearts, each granting unique abilities (or curses), Charlie inadvertently becomes embroiled in a deadly game orchestrated by a shady group known as The Heartbreakers. Players must make choices that impact the flow of the story, recruit allies from a cast of eccentric characters, and confront the moral quandaries of what it means to truly, and literally, have someone else's heart. As they uncover the mystery behind the allure of these hearts, secrets about Charlie's own heart come to light, leading to choices that could change the city and themselves forever.