In "Whose Heart Is It Anyway?", players step into the shoes of Lizzie, a quirky coroner who can communicate with the souls of the deceased. Following a string of mysterious murders in a small town, Lizzie discovers that the killer is taking hearts from their victims, but not for the sake of violence; each heart comes with a unique nightmare that reveals the victim’s darkest secrets. As Lizzie navigates through a web of eccentric townsfolk, hidden truths, and various moral dilemmas, she must decide what to do with the knowledge she gains—expose the killer or protect the secrets of the dead. Each choice affects the outcome, leading to multiple endings based on morality and empathy.