In 'Whose Heart is it, Anyway?', players step into the shoes of Charlie, a sardonic soul who finds themselves in a bizarre realm where metaphysical beings barter for human hearts, each possessing a unique story of love, loss, and insanity. Players navigate through a series of chaotic scenarios ranging from absurd negotiations with heart-harvesting gnomes to engaging in philosophical debates with the 'Heartless' — beings who once had their hearts but traded them for power. The decisions you make affect how much of your own heart you can retain and determine the final outcome, leading to multiple endings filled with unexpected twists, tearing choices, and merciless humor.