Set in a vibrant metropolis, 'Whose Hat Is It Anyway?' follows the misadventures of an amateur detective, Buzz Brewster, who is famed for solving the most ludicrous mysteries. When an infamous hat thief begins stealing iconic hats from local celebrities, Buzz believes this is the case that will put him on the map. Players navigate through a series of humorous scenarios, interviewing quirky characters, solving witty riddles, and gathering clues about the identity of the hat thief. Choices made throughout the game influence the outcome and humor level as players uncover surprising truths about the hats and the people who wear them.