In a world where personal belongings can mysteriously switch hands, players take on the role of a quirky detective named Riley, whose job is to find the rightful owners of a bizarre assortment of items that have shown up in the city. From a rubber chicken that seems to quack when no one is looking to a seemingly cursed lamp that grants terrible wishes, Riley must interact with an eccentric cast of characters, solve bizarre puzzles, and unearth the tangled relationships between the citizens who lost (or misplaced) their belongings. The game features dialogue choices that affect the storyline and the relationships with the characters, allowing players to immerse themselves in the chaos of clue-gathering while trying to keep their sanity intact.